When Co-parenting is High Conflict: Finding a Parenting Model that Fits

When Co-parenting is High Conflict: Finding a Parenting Model that Fits

Shelley Coleman
Shelley Coleman
Child and Adolescent Psychotherapist
Regional Liaison – The Texas Association of Play Therapy

Divorce is hardly “one size fits all”. All caregivers bring their history and expectations to the table when they consider divorce and parenting through this process.  We parents have some very specific ideas of what co-parenting should look and feel like. These ideas are likely based on both the positive and negative ways that we were raised.  In my private psychotherapy practice, I find that one thing is consistent, however.  Parents want to co-parent with the least amount of conflict and difficulty.  They want things to be smoother than they were in the marriage.  They want the autonomy to make their own parenting decisions, though they also hope that the other parent will support their ideas. Mainly, they want their children to navigate the emotional challenges of divorce with the least amount of impact. And, many parents understand that high conflict is a predictor for negative outcomes for their children.

As a Play Therapist, I often work with children who are experiencing high conflict parental divorce. For a child, caregiver conflict is felt as a threat to their own emotional security. A high degree of conflict between caregivers puts children at risk for emotional, behavioral, social, academic and even physical health difficulties.

Specifically, these risks increase when children are:

  • drawn into adult conflict
  • forced to choose sides
  • witness a high degree of conflict
  • asked to serve as communication messengers
  • living in unpredictable environments

One way to decrease the frequency and intensity of parental conflict, is to put a parenting plan and co-parenting model in place. There are many models for co-parenting. And, the one that “works” the best is the one that fits your particular family.

Whichever the model the caregivers choose, I find that there can be goal alignment on a few pieces. In general, parents want less legal involvement and court appearances. They would prefer to work out challenges without paying their attorney.  And, parents typically want smoother transitions between homes as well as less behavior concerns for their children.

There are several, well established models for parenting that can help parents work toward these goals. These include, but are not limited to..

  •  cooperative parenting
  • nesting
  • single parenting
  • parallel parenting

The best known and most recognised model for parenting post divorce is the cooperative model. This model encourages open communication and shared decision making.  This is a great fit for parents who are able to consistently engage in open and respectful dialogue. I find that many parents can work toward this model over time, though this may not always be the starting point.

Another model that suits parents who are able to collaborate, is nesting. In this model, parents move in and out of the home while the children stay put. The caregivers move in accordance with the custody schedule. This model is often used in the early stages of divorce as one parent may be in the process of establishing a new domicile.

In some cases, one parent will choose to not participate in parenting. In this case, there will be a single parent who makes all parenting decisions. The other parent will have minimal to no involvement. This model sometimes develops naturally and may be in line with families where one parent lives abroad or is disengaged in parenting.

For caregivers who have a high degree of conflict, parallel parenting can help lower the tension. In the parallel parenting model, communication is limited and structured. Parents do not disengage or stop communicating, but they do place parameters and boundaries around the way they interact. Caregivers may communicate via an app like Family Wizard or through writing. Each household runs independently of the other home and there is a structured plan in place for parent decisions.

Some of the key aspects of this model include:

  • structured communication such as communicating only via an app or in writing
  • specific plans for when an agreement cannot be found such as using a “tie breaker” like a pediatrician or parent coach
  • using tools to decrease emotions and conflict in communication such as BIFF style emails (brief, informative,friendly, and firm)
  • only communicating around the child or children (communication pertains to school, medical, and schedules)
  • drop off or transitions between homes may occur in public places (school, restaurants)

Of course, caregivers may move through these models or use a combination of models that fit their particular family. It is not uncommon for parents to follow a nesting model while they are separating and establishing new homes. They may then become cooperative parents on most issues, but use a parallel parenting model for some more challenging matters. Parents should be encouraged to assess and determine which model or aspects of a model best “fit” their family and how they choose to implement this.

While the goal may be to work together to parent the children post divorce, there are instances where this is not possible. For parents to work together in any model, the relationship must be free of abuse, threats, and intimidation. Children and their caregivers must first be safe. In some cases, protective or legal interventions are necessary. In any model, collaboration is only possible when all parties are free from harm.

References used in this article.

Eddy, B. (2020). Don’t alienate the kids: Raising resilient children in high-conflict divorce. Unhooked Books.

Anderson, K., & Upthegrove, S. (2025). Parallel parenting with purpose: A practical alternative to co-parenting in high conflict family systems. Journal of Family Trauma, Child Custody & Child Development, 22(3), 354–371. https://doi.org/10.1080/26904586.2025.2555259

Guyette, E., & Harris, S. M. (2024). The impact of divorce education programs on co-parental conflict: Review of programs with parent follow-up reports. Family Court Review, 62(3), 542–561. https://doi.org/10.1111/fcre.12797

About Shelley Coleman

Shelley Coleman is a Licensed Professional Counselor and Supervisor (LPC-S) as well as a Registered Play Therapist and Supervisor (RPT-S). She has 19 years of clinical experience and 10 years of business management experience, and 23 years of parenting experience.  Shelley’s private practice serves children, adolescents and families. She provides parent education, play therapy, child and adolescent therapy, and family therapy. She is trained in EMDR, Play Therapy, TF-CBT, New Ways for Families, and PCIT. Shelley was the 2022-2023 President of the Hill Country Chapter of the Texas Association of Play Therapists and currently serves as Regional Liaison to the Texas Association of Play Therapists.

Shelley Coleman is a Licensed Professional Counsellor and Supervisor (LPC-S) as well as a Registered Play Therapist and Supervisor (RPT-S). She has 18 years of clinical experience, 10 years of business management experience, and 23 years of parenting experience. Shelley's private practice serves children, adolescents and families. She provides parent education, play therapy, child and adolescent therapy, and family therapy. She is trained in EMDR, Play Therapy, TF-CBT, New Ways for Families, and PCIT. Shelley was the 2022-2023 President of the Hill Country Chapter of the Texas Association of Play Therapists and currently serves as Regional Liaison to the Texas Association of Play Therapists.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.