

Clinical Psychologist
The Oak Tree Practice
If you have ever felt yourself drawn back to a relationship you previously decided to leave behind, you are not alone. The question we need to ask when this happens is whether this pull is part of an unhelpful pattern in our life or an informed choice we are making for ourselves.
We all have patterns of relating to others which guide our behaviour, sometimes more than we realise. These often manifest themselves repeatedly throughout our lives in different forms. Sometimes they serve us and sometimes they don’t.
Contrary to what many people assume, having negative experiences in a relationship does not automatically lead us to revise the pattern for next time. This is why you often see people ending up in similar situations repeatedly, such as finding a similar ‘type’ of partner or returning to the same one, even if it doesn’t serve them.
That is not to say that there’s something wrong with going back to someone you had broken up with or finding someone new who is a similar type. Relationship patterns can often be worked on while in a relationship. However, this can take a certain amount of awareness to do, and you may want to ask yourself the question: ‘Am I choosing this or am I repeating a pattern that’s no longer serving me?’
We learn how to relate to others early
The foundation for our relationship patterns is formed in relation to our early caregivers. The infant-carer relationship is one where we are dependent on the other for our survival, so it becomes highly important to us. As babies and children, we’ll do whatever we can to make our caregiver pay us the necessary attention for our needs to be met, this could mean giving subtle emotional cues that the parent picks up, it could mean screaming louder, it could mean detaching emotionally, etc. depending on the responses we receive as well as some biological factors.
We also learn from what we observe in others during this phase. Our caregivers may argue and make up, leave and come back, or avoid each other at any given opportunity while remaining together. This is modelled to us in a way that shapes our expectations of relationships growing up and in adulthood. We may for example learn that an argument is only temporary and we will eventually be reunited, or that arguing is a sign of affection or ‘passion’ in the relationship.
In our adult relationships, these foundations still play a role in the ways we relate to others. After the end of a relationship, we may thus expect that the person will eventually come back, feel drawn to ask for them back, or dissociate from our feelings about them and act as if we don’t really care so we might as well go back. In other words, when we feel drawn to return to a relationship, this could be because we genuinely want to be with that particular person, or it could be a learned pattern of relating and feeling from our past that feels familiar to us.
Familiar doesn’t always mean comfortable
As humans, we are naturally drawn to familiarity. Once, this helped us survive, as staying with what’s familiar, so long as it works, prevents us from stepping into unknown territory where
threats may lurk. Our survival, whether as a hunter in ancient times, searching the wilderness for food, or as a child navigating the territory of a parent’s responses, does not depend so much on comfort as repeating what works. Because of this instinctual tendency, we often stay in relationship patterns even when they lead to significant suffering for us.
This does not mean that we are doomed to repeat such patterns forever. We can all do the work of making changes to serve ourselves and others better. The starting point for any such change is awareness. We can raise our awareness by reflecting on our relationship patterns.
The process of change often comes with some discomfort. It is therefore understandable when people avoid it. However, when a relationship ends, we are only partially in control of this change and difficult feelings are often inevitable.
The experience of ‘the gap’
When ending a relationship, we don’t just lose the person. We also lose every role that person served in our life. Little gestures like good morning messages, the person you talk first about something exciting, company in the evenings, physical affection, inside jokes, and even small ordinary things that didn’t seem important at the time. In other words, there is suddenly an open gap in our life.
This can lead us to miss the person, even if we know in our rational mind that it was for the best. Whether we still love the person or feel enraged by the thought of them, or anything in between, there is still no denying that there is a loss to be dealt with. Something needs our attention and it may not be pleasant.
Even when we know a breakup was for the best, we are still likely to experience some level of grief after a relationship has ended. People experience and respond to grief differently but generally go through a process of challenging emotions that require space and attention. If we go through the grief process in a healthy way, we can move forward with a clearer mind than we could if we suppressed our feelings.
The gap which was initially filled with grief can then gradually become space for what we choose to invite into our life.
Going back isn’t automatically a mistake
It is important to acknowledge that not every breakup is meant to be forever. Many choose to get back together and find ways of making it work again. People, and their relationship patterns, can change. Sometimes, people separate, reflect, work on themselves, and reunite with a stronger relationship dynamic.
So how do we decide whether this is a good idea? There is no correct answer, but it may not be as simple as, ‘do I still feel drawn to them?’ As we have seen, simply being drawn to someone can result from various factors and may have nothing to do with how good you are for each other. Instead, we might ask questions like the following:
- Am I missing this person, or am I missing companionship?
- Am I remembering the relationship as it really was, or as I hoped it could be?
- Am I drawn towards what I know, because the alternative feels uncertain?
- And perhaps most importantly: what has actually changed?
This can be quite tricky work to do alone, and sometimes people seek professional help to navigate this territory.
Relationship counselling
Contrary to what many believe, relationship counselling does not necessarily aim to keep people together. Sometimes the aim is to help partners figure our whether they are right for each other or not, what needs to be worked on before getting back together, facilitate a healthy breakup, have a space to discuss the practicalities of a breakup etc.
It is a space where couples can work on finding out what is in their best interest rather than reacting to feelings and relationship patterns. A trained counsellor or therapist can help to raise awareness, make sense of issues that come up, and facilitate reflection. They are also there to help couples navigate and process emotional content that comes up in sessions.
A relationship counsellor is there to help each person feel equally heard and considered. They will work with the couple to find a way forward that serves everyone the best way possible whatever the outcome might be.
The bottom line
Ultimately, feeling drawn back to a familiar relationship is not necessarily a sign that we should return, nor is it a sign that we shouldn’t. What matters is understanding where that pull comes from and whether returning is a choice that serves us in the present, rather than a repetition of something from our past. With greater awareness, we can begin to recognise our patterns, make sense of our feelings, and create space for relationships that genuinely work for us.
About Dr Erlend Slettevold
Dr Erlend Slettevold is a Clinical Psychologist at The Oak Tree Practice. His qualifications include Psychology BSc, Psychology MSd and a Doctorate in Clinical Psychology.
